Most Popular

Judge Losing Patience in Ripple and XRP Lawsuit As SEC Changes Its Story Too Many Times: Crypto Legal Expert

A crypto legal expert says that the Judge in the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission’s (SEC) case against Ripple Labs is losing patience with the regulatory agency for flip-flopping on its story.

In a new video update, attorney Jeremy Hogan, who has been closely following the case, says that Judge Sarah Netburn is getting tired of the SEC continually filing objections to her order of producing specific documents.

As you know, for over a year and a half now, Ripple has been seeking discovery of the emails related to [William] Hinman’s 2018 speech, and they still have not received them. I’ve never seen a discreet discovery battle go on this long. Never.

Judge Netburn has ordered them to produce the documents on numerous occasions and the SEC continues to file objection after objection and the latest objection was maybe just one objection too far…

The SEC continues to change its story on whether Hinman’s speech was his personal opinion, an SEC opinion, or more recently, that it was his division’s opinion. And listening to the hearing on the SEC’s attorney-client privilege argument, which I did, I got a sense that the Judge has just about heard enough.”

In 2018, Hinman, then Director of the SEC’s Division of Corporate Finance, said that he doesn’t consider leading smart contract platform Ethereum (ETH) as a security. Two years later, the SEC went on to sue Ripple Labs for selling XRP as an unregistered security.

Hogan then quotes a statement by Judge Netburn reprimanding the SEC for altering its story.

I hate to interrupt you, but you just said something different to me. You said that the was given by Director Hinman in his capacity as director of corporate finance. That seems different to me than what you said a year ago. 

Am I misremembering? Because when we were discussion whether he should be deposed, as I recall, there was an argument from the SEC that what he said really had no bearing on this litigation because he wasn’t speaking on behalf of that division; that he was just speaking at a personal event. And there was a lot of attention focused on the disclaimers. But you just said now that he was speaking as director on behalf of that division.’” 

The crypto legal expert adds a quote from court documents showing how Judge Netburn gave an “uncharacteristic” feedback to the SEC to show her frustration to the changing stance of the regulatory agency.

“‘The hypocrisy in arguing to the Court, on the one hand, that the speech is not relevant to the market’s understanding of how or whether the SEC will regulate cryptocurrency, and on the other hand, that Hinman sought and obtained legal advice from SEC counsel when drafting the speech, suggests that the SEC is adopting its litigation positions to further its desired goal, and not out of faithful allegiance to the law.’”


XRP Etched Pub Glasses, 16oz

    Leave Your Comment

    Forgot Password

    Ledger Nano X - The secure hardware wallet